Hey Alex it might be a good idea --now that I think of it-- to seperate all these games into either a 'pre-release/beta' or 'completed' listing.
I noticed that you put up Garland's Quest --and though I'm greatly flattered -- it's not a complete game, or even what I'd consider a 'beta' since all the pieces aren't in place to make it into a full game.
This sort of thought brought me to thinking that we could have 2 votes. 1 for Best of All Time for 'beta' state games and Best of All Time for 'completed' games.
That or we should just axe the non-completed games form the list and only consider ones that are complete.
I'll see what I can do to add to the list later this week if I have time. I'm usually on top of most things going on so I definitely know a few myself.
Besides everyone can nominate for best game of all time right?